
The British Retail Consortium (BRC) is urging the government to act on recommendations from Alan Milburn’s report on youth employment. The report, titled From a Welfare State to a Working State, highlights the challenges of rising employment costs for retailers, making it harder to create entry-level jobs.
In response to the report, BRC chief executive Helen Dickinson emphasized that preparing young people for employment is only half the battle. The government must also ensure businesses have the confidence and capacity to create jobs.
Retail’s Role in Youth Employment
Retail plays a key role in providing local, entry-level opportunities, with one in five people starting their working lives in the sector. Dickinson highlighted the importance of retail as a first step on the career ladder, but warned that rising employment costs are threatening this pathway.
The BRC is backing Milburn’s recommendation to raise the National Insurance contributions (NICs) threshold for under-25s, initially focusing on retail and hospitality. This proposal is seen as essential, with the BRC citing 120,000 retail roles lost between 2024 and 2026, while employment costs for the sector increased by £6.5 billion.
Employment Costs and Regulatory Burdens
The rise in employment costs is attributed to higher National Insurance contributions and above-inflation increases to the National Living Wage. Dickinson warned that additional regulatory burdens, such as the Guaranteed Hours reforms, could make employers more reluctant to recruit, reducing opportunities for younger workers.
The BRC also expressed concern over the impact of employment legislation on recruitment, calling for a cautious approach to implementing reforms. Dickinson said the Employment Rights Act must protect workers without discouraging businesses from hiring.
As retailers handle these challenges, the need for a balanced approach becomes evident. National Minimum Wage rates and employment regulations must be carefully considered to ensure they support both workers and employers. This delicate balance is key for maintaining a healthy job market, especially in sectors like retail where entry-level opportunities are vital for young people’s career development.
Apprenticeships and Skills Investment
Apprenticeships are another area of concern, with retailers contributing hundreds of millions of pounds to the Growth and Skills Levy but using only around half of the funding available. The BRC warned that reducing government funding for apprenticeships for those aged over 25 by 25% could make it more expensive for retailers to develop existing employees.
Dickinson called for all money raised through the Levy to be made available for skills and apprenticeship investment, rather than returning to the Treasury. The BRC welcomed proposals to double the number of apprenticeships for under-25s and introduce pre-employment apprenticeship courses, but said these ambitions needed to be matched by greater flexibility in how retailers could use Levy funding.
The BRC’s involvement in initiatives like Opening Shift highlights the importance of work experience in overcoming barriers to employment. By offering placements, retailers can help young people gain the experience needed to compete for jobs, while also identifying areas where additional support is required to ensure a smooth transition from education to work.
Incentives and Support for Employers
Milburn’s proposals include cash incentives of up to £7,000 for employers hiring young people who have been out of work or education for more than six months, alongside £2,500 for taking on a new apprentice aged 16 to 24. Dickinson said these incentives could make a meaningful difference, provided the support was straightforward for employers to access.
The proposed Youth Opportunity Test, which would assess the impact of policies on youth employment, was also welcomed by the BRC. Dickinson described Milburn’s report as a call to action, addressing both a moral and economic crisis. For retailers, the report puts the cost of employing people firmly back in the spotlight, emphasizing the need for measures that make hiring financially viable.